- The DMA: The Regulation Changing Digital Rules
- Gatekeepers and Review Platforms: Who’s in the Spotlight
- Self-Preferencing Ban: Impact on Google Reviews
- Data and Review Portability: What Changes for Your Business
- Interoperability Between Review Platforms
- The DMA and Review Ranking Transparency
- Opportunities for Alternative Platforms
- DMA Penalties: Amounts and Enforcement
- Review Strategy Under the New DMA Framework
- Conclusion: A More Competitive Review Ecosystem
The Digital Markets Act (Regulation (EU) 2022/1925) is redefining the relationship between major digital platforms and the businesses that depend on them. For businesses managing their online reputation, the DMA isn’t just another piece of legislation: it’s the instrument that can break the de facto monopoly that Google holds over the review ecosystem and open new visibility opportunities on alternative platforms.
In this analysis, the Maps&Más Team examines the obligations the DMA imposes on digital ecosystem “gatekeepers,” how these obligations specifically affect review platforms, and what opportunities open up for businesses that adapt their strategy to the new regulatory framework. To understand how the DMA interacts with other European regulations, check our article on the Digital Services Act (DSA) and reviews.
The DMA: The Regulation Changing Digital Rules
The Digital Markets Act became fully effective in March 2024. Unlike previous regulations focused on consumer protection or privacy, the DMA has a distinct objective: ensuring fair competition in digital markets.
The DMA doesn’t directly regulate reviews, but its provisions on self-preferencing, data portability, and interoperability have a transformative impact on how review platforms function and how businesses can manage their online reputation.
The European Commission has designated six companies as gatekeepers: Alphabet (Google), Amazon, Apple, ByteDance (TikTok), Meta, and Microsoft. Of these, Google and Amazon have the greatest direct impact on the review ecosystem.
Gatekeepers and Review Platforms: Who’s in the Spotlight
Google: The Dominant Gatekeeper
Google is by far the most affected actor under the DMA in the review context. Its integrated ecosystem — Google Search, Google Maps, Google Business Profile — gives it a dominant position that the DMA seeks to regulate.
Platforms Not Designated as Gatekeepers
Trustpilot, TripAdvisor, Yelp, and other review platforms are not directly subject to the DMA, but benefit enormously from the obligations it imposes on Google and Amazon.
Self-Preferencing Ban: Impact on Google Reviews
Article 6(5) of the DMA prohibits gatekeepers from favoring their own services in rankings and search results. This has direct implications for Google reviews:
Before the DMA: Google Maps reviews appeared in prominent positions (Local Pack, Knowledge Panel) while TripAdvisor or TheFork reviews were relegated to general organic results.
After the DMA: Google is required not to favor its reviews over those from competing platforms. In practice, this means:
- Greater visibility for Trustpilot, TripAdvisor, and other platform reviews in search results
- Requirement to show review aggregates from multiple sources in business information panels
- More equitable access for alternative platforms to local business data
The self-preferencing ban makes maintaining quality reviews on multiple platforms more profitable than ever. If you've been focusing exclusively on Google, now is the time to diversify toward Trustpilot, TripAdvisor, and industry-specific platforms. To choose the most suitable platform, check our comparison Trustpilot vs Google Reviews.
Data and Review Portability: What Changes for Your Business
Article 6(9) of the DMA requires gatekeepers to allow effective data portability. In the review context:
For reviewers: users can export their published Google reviews and take them to other platforms, reducing dependence on Google as the primary opinion repository.
For businesses: portability opens the possibility of aggregating reviews from multiple platforms on your own website or in a centralized management platform.
Practical limitations: portability doesn’t mean a business can “transfer” its Google reviews to another platform. Portable data belongs to the user (reviewer), not the business.
"Review portability under the DMA is probably the most underestimated change in the regulatory landscape. In the medium term, the ability for reviewers to transfer their history between platforms will significantly reduce Google's lock-in effect and create a more liquid, competitive review market."
— Digital Strategy Team, Maps&MásInteroperability Between Review Platforms
The DMA promotes interoperability as a guiding principle. For the review ecosystem, this could mean in the future:
- Standardized aggregation: technical standards for review platforms to share data in a structured way
- Cross-verification: systems to verify reviewer authenticity on one platform using their verified identity on another
- Unified scoring: the possibility for consumers to see an aggregated score from multiple platforms at a glance
The DMA and Review Ranking Transparency
Article 6(5) also requires gatekeepers to provide transparency about ranking criteria. Google must explain how it determines which reviews appear first, what criteria it uses to filter or highlight reviews, how it calculates aggregate scores, and what factors determine a business’s Local Pack position.
Opportunities for Alternative Platforms
The DMA is creating a redistribution effect in the review ecosystem:
Trustpilot: positioned as the primary DMA beneficiary in Europe. Its verified, invitation-based review model aligns with Omnibus Directive authenticity requirements.
TripAdvisor: reinforces its position in the tourism and hospitality sector. Google’s obligation not to self-preference especially benefits TripAdvisor.
Industry-specific platforms: the DMA opens space for niche platforms (Healthgrades for healthcare, TheFork for restaurants, Houzz for home services) previously overshadowed by Google’s dominance.
DMA Penalties: Amounts and Enforcement
| Type of Non-Compliance | Maximum Penalty | Enforcement |
|---|---|---|
| DMA obligation violation | 10% of global annual revenue | By European Commission decision |
| Repeat offense | 20% of global annual revenue | After a first penalty |
| Systematic non-compliance | Structural remedies (business unit divestiture) | In extreme cases |
| Non-cooperation with investigation | 1% of global annual revenue | For obstruction |
Review Strategy Under the New DMA Framework
1. Active diversification: don’t rely exclusively on Google. Allocate resources to generate quality reviews on Trustpilot, TripAdvisor, and industry-specific platforms.
2. Leverage portability: when portability mechanisms are fully operational, help your customers transfer their positive reviews to platforms where they’ll have the most impact.
3. Multi-platform monitoring: implement monitoring tools covering all platforms where you have a presence.
4. Enriched content: reviews with photos, videos, and specific details gain relevance in an ecosystem that rewards authenticity.
5. Algorithmic transparency: leverage the transparency the DMA requires from Google to optimize your profile using known ranking criteria.
Conclusion: A More Competitive Review Ecosystem
The Digital Markets Act is democratizing the review ecosystem in Europe. The self-preferencing ban, data portability, and transparency requirements are creating a market where review quality matters more than the platform where they’re published.
For businesses, the DMA represents both an opportunity and a challenge. The opportunity lies in diversification. The challenge lies in complexity: managing reputation across a multi-platform ecosystem requires more resources and greater strategic sophistication.
Businesses that adapt first to the new regulatory framework will have a lasting competitive advantage in a market where online reputation remains the top consumer decision factor.
⚖️ Need advice on online reputation?
Our team advises you on compliance, regulations and legal review management strategies.
💬 Consult an expert →