- Introduction: the legal dilemma of online reviews
- Spanish legal framework: the three key laws
- The Omnibus Directive and its transposition in Spain
- Fake reviews vs. incentivised reviews: the crucial difference
- Platform terms of service vs. national legislation
- Risk assessment: platform vs. legal penalties
- Grey areas: review management and acceleration
- Compliance strategies for businesses
Introduction: the legal dilemma of online reviews
The question “Is it legal to buy reviews in Spain?” is possibly the most frequently asked query amongst local business owners seeking to improve their digital reputation. The answer, as is often the case in legal matters, is not a simple yes or no — it depends on multiple factors: the type of review, the platform, the methodology used and the applicable regulatory framework.
This article is for informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. For your business's specific circumstances, we recommend consulting a solicitor specialising in digital law and unfair competition.
Spanish legal framework: the three key laws
General Law for Consumer and User Defence (LGDCU) — Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007, amended by Law 4/2022 transposing the Omnibus Directive. Expressly prohibits unfair commercial practices, including the dissemination of fake reviews or manipulation of consumer opinions to mislead.
1. LGDCU — establishes that presenting fictitious reviews as if from real consumers, failing to inform whether reviews have been verified, and commissioning the publication of false opinions are all unfair practices. Penalties range from €10,000 for minor infringements to €1,000,000 for very serious ones, potentially reaching 4% of annual turnover.
2. Unfair Competition Law (LCD) — prohibits acts of deception and practices that distort consumer economic behaviour. Competitors harmed by fake reviews can bring civil actions for cessation, declaration, rectification and damages.
3. EU Digital Services Act (DSA) — Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, applicable since February 2026, obliges platforms to establish mechanisms to combat illegal content, including fraudulent reviews.
The Omnibus Directive and its transposition in Spain
The Directive (EU) 2019/2161 establishes three fundamental obligations: businesses must inform whether they have procedures to verify that reviews come from genuine consumers; the publication of fake reviews is expressly prohibited; and businesses must be transparent about the criteria used to order and display reviews.
Fake reviews vs. incentivised reviews: the crucial difference
Fake reviews (clearly illegal): opinions completely fabricated by people who have never used the service or product. These unequivocally violate the LGDCU, the Unfair Competition Law and constitute misleading advertising.
Incentivised reviews (legal grey area): opinions from real customers who receive some type of incentive (discount, gift, additional service) for sharing their experience. These are not inherently illegal if they reflect a genuine consumer experience, but the incentive should be disclosed and content must never be conditional on a specific rating.
Review management and acceleration services: professional services that facilitate real customers leaving their opinions more efficiently — providing tools for systematic contact, simplifying the process with direct links and QR codes, and automated reminders. These do not create fictitious content.
Professional reputation management services like Maps&Más operate in the third category: we facilitate real people with genuine experiences sharing their opinion. We do not generate fictitious content, use bots, or fabricate false identities. This distinction is key for legal compliance.
Platform terms of service vs. national legislation
A common legal error is confusing a breach of terms of service with illegality under national law. Terms of service are a private contract between platform and user — violating them can result in account suspension or review removal, but does not in itself constitute illegal conduct. Where law and ToS clearly converge is in the prohibition of completely fake reviews.
Risk assessment: platform vs. legal penalties
The greatest real threat for most SMEs is not an administrative fine but Google's algorithmic penalty. A business losing its Local Pack position can see revenues fall between 30% and 50% immediately. Learn more about the Local Pack and how to position yourself.
Grey areas: review management and acceleration
Actively requesting reviews from your customers is completely legal — Google itself encourages businesses to do so. What the ToS do not permit is offering a direct incentive in exchange.
Professional intermediation services that optimise the process (automated reminders, direct links, post-sale follow-up) resemble a legitimate marketing strategy more than an unfair practice.
Reviews from customers with accelerated experiences — when a service provides real people with a genuine experience (even if facilitated) so they can then share their honest opinion — represent one of the most doctrinally debated scenarios. The legal key lies in the authenticity of the opinion expressed.
Compliance strategies for businesses
- Verify authenticity: Ensure all reviews come from customers with real, verifiable experiences
- Document the commercial relationship: Keep records proving reviewers were actual customers (invoices, tickets, bookings)
- Do not dictate content: Never tell customers what to write or what rating to give
- Transparency with incentives: If you offer any benefit in exchange for a review, ensure this is properly reflected
- Respect platform ToS: Although breaching them is not illegal, practical consequences can be devastating
- Diversify platforms: Distribute reviews across Google, TripAdvisor and Trustpilot according to your sector
- Gradual and natural pace: Avoid artificial review spikes — a constant, gradual flow is safer and more credible
The answer to “Is it legal to buy reviews?” is legally nuanced. Buying completely fake reviews is illegal under current Spanish and European legislation. However, professional reputation management services working with real experiences and authentic customers operate within a framework of reasonable legality, especially when they prioritise transparency, verifiability and regulatory compliance.
⚖️ Need advice on online reputation?
Our team advises you on compliance, regulations and legal review management strategies.
💬 Consult an expert →