- The DMA: the regulation changing the rules of the digital game
- Gatekeepers and review platforms: who is in the spotlight
- Self-preferencing prohibition: impact on Google Reviews
- Data portability and reviews: what changes for your business
- Transparency in review rankings
- Opportunities for alternative platforms
- DMA penalties: amounts and enforcement
- Review strategy in the new DMA framework
The Digital Markets Act (Regulation (EU) 2022/1925) is redefining the relationship between large digital platforms and the businesses that depend on them. For companies managing their online reputation, the DMA is not just another piece of legislation: it is the instrument that could break the de facto monopoly Google holds over the review ecosystem and open new visibility opportunities on alternative platforms.
In this analysis, the Maps&Más team examines the obligations the DMA imposes on digital ecosystem “gatekeepers”, how these obligations specifically affect review platforms, and what opportunities open up for businesses that adapt their strategy to the new regulatory framework. To understand how the DMA interacts with other European regulations, consult our article on the Digital Services Act (DSA) and reviews.
The DMA: the regulation changing the rules of the digital game
The Digital Markets Act came fully into force in March 2024, with effective compliance obligations for platforms designated as “gatekeepers”. Unlike previous regulations that focused on consumer protection or privacy, the DMA has a distinct objective: guaranteeing fair competition in digital markets.
The European Commission has designated six companies as gatekeepers: Alphabet (Google), Amazon, Apple, ByteDance (TikTok), Meta and Microsoft. Of these, Google and Amazon have the greatest direct impact on the review ecosystem.
Gatekeepers and review platforms: who is in the spotlight
Google is by far the most affected actor. Its integrated ecosystem — Google Search, Google Maps, Google Business Profile — grants it a dominant position that the DMA seeks to regulate. Amazon operates Europe’s largest product review system. Trustpilot, TripAdvisor, Yelp and other review platforms are not directly subject to the DMA but benefit enormously from the obligations it imposes on Google and Amazon.
Self-preferencing prohibition: impact on Google Reviews
Article 6(5) of the DMA prohibits gatekeepers from favouring their own services in rankings and search results.
Before the DMA: when you searched for a restaurant on Google, Google Maps reviews appeared in prominent positions (Local Pack, Knowledge Panel) whilst TripAdvisor or TheFork reviews were relegated to generic organic results.
After the DMA: Google is obliged not to favour its reviews over those of competing platforms. In practice, this is resulting in greater visibility of Trustpilot, TripAdvisor and other platform reviews in search results, a requirement to show review aggregates from multiple sources, and more equitable access for alternative platforms.
The self-preferencing prohibition makes maintaining quality reviews on multiple platforms more profitable than ever. If you have been concentrating exclusively on Google, now is the time to diversify towards Trustpilot, TripAdvisor and industry-specific platforms. For help choosing, consult our comparison Trustpilot vs Google Reviews.
Data portability and reviews: what changes for your business
Article 6(9) of the DMA establishes that gatekeepers must allow effective data portability. In the reviews context:
For reviewers: users can export their published Google reviews and take them to other platforms, reducing dependence on Google as the primary repository of opinions.
For businesses: portability opens the possibility of aggregating reviews from multiple platforms on your own website, always respecting terms of use and reviewer rights.
"Review portability under the DMA is probably the most underestimated change in the regulatory landscape. In the medium term, the ability for reviewers to transfer their history between platforms will significantly reduce Google's lock-in effect and create a more liquid and competitive review market."
— Digital Strategy Team, Maps&MásTransparency in review rankings
Article 6(5) also requires gatekeepers to provide transparency about ranking criteria. Google must explain how it determines which reviews appear first, what criteria it uses to filter or highlight reviews, and what factors determine a business’s position in the Local Pack.
Opportunities for alternative platforms
The DMA is creating a redistribution effect benefiting alternative platforms:
- Trustpilot: positioned as the main DMA beneficiary in Europe, with its verified invitation review model fitting Omnibus Directive authenticity requirements
- TripAdvisor: reinforcing its position in tourism and hospitality, with reviews now competing on equal terms in the SERP
- Industry-specific platforms: the DMA opens space for niche platforms (Doctoralia for healthcare, TheFork for restaurants, Houzz for home) previously overshadowed by Google
- Emerging platforms: new platforms based on blockchain or decentralised verification find a favourable regulatory environment
DMA penalties: amounts and enforcement
| Type of non-compliance | Maximum penalty | Enforcement |
|---|---|---|
| Breach of DMA obligations | 10% of global annual turnover | By European Commission decision |
| Repeat offence | 20% of global annual turnover | After a first penalty |
| Systematic non-compliance | Structural remedies (sale of business units) | In extreme cases |
| Failure to cooperate with investigation | 1% of global annual turnover | For obstruction |
Review strategy in the new DMA framework
To capitalise on the opportunities the DMA offers, businesses should adapt their review strategy:
1. Active diversification: do not depend exclusively on Google. Allocate resources to generating quality reviews on Trustpilot, TripAdvisor and industry-specific platforms.
2. Leverage portability: when portability mechanisms are fully operational, facilitate your customers in transferring their positive reviews to the platforms where they have the greatest impact.
3. Multi-platform monitoring: implement monitoring tools covering all platforms where you have a presence, not just Google.
4. Optimise for transparency: with Google obliged to explain its ranking criteria, design your review strategy based on known criteria rather than assumptions.
The DMA represents a structural shift towards a more competitive, transparent and diversified review ecosystem. Businesses that position themselves early in this multi-platform ecosystem will have a clear advantage over those that continue to depend exclusively on Google.
⚖️ Need advice on online reputation?
Our team advises you on compliance, regulations and legal review management strategies.
💬 Consult an expert →